All the sages and The Miscreant's identy

Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
edited August 2007 in Zelda Comic
Yes, as we all now know the Miscreant was a sage. Now all that is left to do is figure out which sage he is. Now here is my theory of deduction.

A) It can't be anyone who visited Link.
B) It can't be a girl (the miscreant seems like a guy and we all know it)

This Leaves Darunia as the only option for a sage. Now this isn't practical as stated in (insert comic number here) Darunia was with the sages. So there must be an eight sage. If there is an eighth sage then the whole domain of Hyrule would be thrown into chaos. Also if you have any better ideas let me know.
«1345

Comments

  • deku12345deku12345
    edited June 2007
    I'm pretty sure its a character that has never been revealed as a sage, because Mario has stated before that people have (unknowingly) correctly guessed the idenity of the miscreant. And its pretty clear its none of the 7 sages. So its someone else.
  • mariomario
    edited June 2007
    To be fair, people have guessed The Miscreant to be a sage in the past, so that very well could have been the unwittingly correct guess.
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    Looking at the past information provided I think it's (and don't laugh at me for this) Mido. I mean he has a town named after him and only the sages have towns named after them so it makes sense. right?
  • DrLeopoldStrabismusDrLeopoldStrabismus
    edited June 2007
    I'm the Miscreant, it's for sure.
  • deku12345deku12345
    edited June 2007
    mario wrote: »
    To be fair, people have guessed The Miscreant to be a sage in the past, so that very well could have been the unwittingly correct guess.

    Curse you and your logic, Mario!

    The Mido thing is pretty plausible, but I spose we won't know til Mario declares it so.
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    deku12345 wrote: »
    Curse you and your logic, Mario!

    I'll second that
  • hlavcohlavco
    edited June 2007
    Isn't Mido that annoying Kokiri kid?

    And if so, wouldn't he be unable to leave the forest?
  • mariomario
    edited June 2007
    Saria seemed to be okay leaving the forest, once she attained sagehood.
  • AgentcelAgentcel
    edited June 2007
    Not a sage we already know:
    sagesgf5.png

    Also, the Miscreant could be a girl.
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    Yes, but that was in the sacred realm not Hyrule. It would seem that as the Sacred realm is magical Saria could stay there, but anywhere else in normal Hyrule isn't likely.
  • mariomario
    edited June 2007
    Actually, that's a house in Rauru Town.
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    mario wrote: »
    Actually, that's a house in Rauru Town.

    That's still in normal old Hyrule isn't it?
  • mariomario
    edited June 2007
    Yes, but you were saying it was in the Sacred Realm. It isn't.
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    I was referring to Ocarina of Time in which Saria first appears as a sage. This means that your comic creates tremendous plot holes. Just like every good comic should.
  • BehemothBehemoth
    edited June 2007
    I don't think they are really there so much as projecting their essenses. Like when they create the bridge for Link. Even now, Saria is probably not physically there, even though she is able to interact with her environment.
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    That has to be one of the best ideas I've heard all day. Thank You Behemoth
  • MrCheezeMrCheeze
    edited June 2007
    I still think it's Kasuto, though Mido makes sense too.
    Or Majora.
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    Kasuto?
  • BehemothBehemoth
    edited June 2007
    Hey, Mario. I don't recall how much information you're willing to give away but, is it definitely a character from the Zelda world? Is it possible that the miscreant is like, an Ice-climber or something?
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    Well if it wasn't a Zelda character from somewhere how could anyone guess who he was correctly as Mario said
  • MrCheezeMrCheeze
    edited June 2007
    Kasuto = the town that seems not to be named after anybody in Zelda II.
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    MrCheeze wrote: »
    Kasuto = the town that seems not to be named after anybody in Zelda II.

    That makes the most sense, and we all know that with the most sense comes the most confusion.
  • AgentcelAgentcel
    edited June 2007
    Behemoth wrote: »
    Is it possible that the miscreant is like, an Ice-climber or something?

    OH GOD NO.
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    Agentcel wrote: »
    OH GOD NO.

    I just kinda dismissed the ice-climber thing. Now that someone has said it I agree.:o
  • brucebruce
    edited June 2007
    Agentcel wrote: »
    OH GOD NO.

    Maybe he's an anthropomorphised horse phallus, eh AC?

    But in all truth, I suspect that should any of us, somehow get it right (a nigh on impossibility) Mario will just change who he is.
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    Well there aren't that many characters that could qualify as being a sage of that awesomeness so he can't change it too often
  • X'o'LoreX'o'Lore
    edited June 2007
    Night Lord wrote: »
    Maybe he's an anthropomorphised horse phallus, eh AC?

    ...Well, he can be kind of a dick sometimes, but I don't think I'd go that far. (and let that joke die please. It wasn't even funny the first time)
  • jcjc
    edited June 2007
    I like your funny comic.
  • AgentcelAgentcel
    edited June 2007
    I didn't even say "Hey" that time....
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    Can we get back on topic please.

© Vanilla Keystone Theme 2023