All the sages and The Miscreant's identy

135

Comments

  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    Agentcel wrote: »
    You're becoming...one of them. The bad pun monsters.

    Yes, so many people have become victims of the bad pun monster. luckily in most cases the effects wear off in ten to twelve posts.
  • BehemothBehemoth
    edited June 2007
    the almighty aardvark wrote: »
    Ice Climber+hood= Miscreant+hood

    Ice climber - hood= miscreant - hood

    Therefore, Ice climber= miscreant! ... (I think)
    Ocarina of Twilight wrote: »
    You know though it probably ian't an ice climber his logic makes it so. Why must the system of logic be undermined so easily. Wait, why do I care?

    As much as I'd like to see a good argument for it being an Ice Climber, just because an argument is logically sound, does not mean it is valid. You must assess whether or not each statement is true. Both (Ice Climber + Hood = Miscreant + Hood), which we'll call "a", and (Ice Climber - Hood = Miscreant - Hood), which we'll call "b", are unsubstanciated. There is nothing to prove either a or b are true, nor is there anything to prove that (Ice Climber = Miscreant), which we'll call "c" is true.

    If a+b then c: If a+b=d, then d is true iff both a and b are true. So, if d then c: This statement is false iff d is true and c is false. i.e. if a+b then c is a true statement, as are if (not a)+b then (not c), if a+(not b) then (not c), and if (not a)+(not b) then (not c). However, this still leaves the validity of all of the parts of the statement in question.
  • mariomario
    edited June 2007
    I said I liked his logic.
  • BehemothBehemoth
    edited June 2007
    Fix'd
  • geokogeoko
    edited June 2007
    Mario liked his logic. that's FTW if there ever was one.
  • UnknownUnknown
    edited June 2007
    Maybe the miscreant is Talon.
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited June 2007
    I doubt it. Talon is too lazy and fat and non-magicaly.
  • the almighty aardvarkthe almighty aardvark
    edited July 2007
    Considering that the revealing comic is drawing ever nearer, I think that we should give one more shot at guessing the miscreant's identity. List whoever you think the miscreant is going to be and we will see if any of our guesses were correct.

    1. Kabuto
  • mariomario
    edited July 2007
    I think they're already listed elsewhere in this thread. Unless you've got new guesses.
  • BehemothBehemoth
    edited July 2007
    I think he means give your final, official guess.

    I'm gonna go with Nes.
  • hlavcohlavco
    edited July 2007
    Link's uncle!
  • X'o'LoreX'o'Lore
    edited July 2007
    Gray Link. The half-brother to Link and Dark Link that everyone forgot about and he's really pissed about it.
  • AgentcelAgentcel
    edited July 2007
    Captain N is my final guess.
  • Amoeba BoyAmoeba Boy
    edited July 2007
    My money's on Clark Kent.
  • MrCheezeMrCheeze
    edited July 2007
    Some character no one pays attention too. Sort of like Bub. (No offence to him, not that he's able to take offence)
  • Ocarina of TwilightOcarina of Twilight
    edited July 2007
    I'm goin' with... Okay I have no freakin idea, but Dark Link works for me
  • godgod
    edited July 2007
    Once again, Old Man Ulrira.
  • daraikenudaraikenu
    edited July 2007
    You know, I'm gonna think outside the box here, instead of thinking Ocarina of Time or Link's Adventure, I'm gonna go Wind Waker on this one. There were four sages mentioned on it --Makar, Medli, Fado, and Laruto--so it could be possible either on of them could be the Miscreant.
  • deku12345deku12345
    edited July 2007
    I'm gonna go with Mido. Because hes a jerk-face.
  • MrCheezeMrCheeze
    edited July 2007
    After seeing comic 299, maybe he is mario.
  • a_link_in_the_futurea_link_in_the_future
    edited July 2007
    it's Kapora Gabora(the owl from Ocarina of Time). The gossip stone did said he was a sage that died and was reborn(I forgot what that's called).
  • godgod
    edited July 2007
    Re-incarnated?
  • BehemothBehemoth
    edited July 2007
    You mean reincarnation?
  • mariomario
    edited July 2007
    Why red text?
  • Professor MacJakeProfessor MacJake
    edited July 2007
    for dramatic effect!!!1!
  • a_link_in_the_futurea_link_in_the_future
    edited July 2007
    mario wrote: »
    Why red text?

    Why black text?
  • mariomario
    edited July 2007
    Not really a valid question. Black text is the default if nothing is specified, but red text is voluntary and deliberate. So I can only assume there to be a reason you chose to go against the norm. Usually colored or otherwise altered text is used for emphatic purposes, but if you use red exclusively, it looks more like you just want your posts to stand out somehow. If this is the case, having a unique avatar is usually more effective.

    Unless... Gasp! You're The Miscreant!
  • a_link_in_the_futurea_link_in_the_future
    edited July 2007
    Noooo!! Now everyone knows who I am! Now realy I do red because that's just what I do on all forums blogs etc. no other reason.
  • the almighty aardvarkthe almighty aardvark
    edited July 2007
    Of course, if everyone starts using red text, only the black text users will stand out.
  • MrCheezeMrCheeze
    edited July 2007
    [highlight]Blasphemy![/highlight]

© Vanilla Keystone Theme 2023